The 5 Best Ice Cream/Frozen Yogurt Shops

A scoop of ice cream can be the perfect reward after a mountain adventure, a downtown shopping trip or a warm summer afternoon. From old-fashioned soda fountains and colorful candy shops to neighborhood markets and country stores, the Yampa Valley offers plenty of places to enjoy a frozen treat. The Best of the Boat 2026 takes a look at local favorites serving cones, sundaes, milkshakes and other sweet ways to cool off.

The Clark Store

Old-fashioned charm and a convenient North Routt County location make The Clark Store a popular stop for ice cream lovers exploring the countryside north of Steamboat Springs. The historic general store features an ice cream counter serving hand-dipped scoops, waffle cones, sundaes, milkshakes and floats in classic flavors. Along with frozen treats, visitors can browse groceries, outdoor supplies and deli offerings. Its location along County Road 129 makes the store a welcome stop for residents, campers and travelers heading toward Pearl Lake and the surrounding wilderness.

Lyon's Corner Drug

A taste of downtown Steamboat Springs history comes with every scoop at Lyon's Corner Drug, a longtime pharmacy and soda fountain at Ninth Street and Lincoln Avenue. Operating for more than a century, the business preserves the tradition of the neighborhood drugstore counter with hand-scooped sundaes, ice cream sodas, thick milkshakes, malts and banana splits. Classic syrups and rich ice cream bring familiar flavors to the menu, while counter seating adds to the nostalgic experience. The soda fountain remains a gathering place for families, shoppers and visitors.

Wild Plum Market

Convenience and variety make Wild Plum Market a destination for frozen desserts near the base of Steamboat Ski Resort. The independent specialty grocer offers soft-serve ice cream, rotating gelato flavors, premium packaged ice creams and frozen treats from regional dairies. Organic, dairy-free and vegan selections provide alternatives for customers with different dietary preferences. With additional offerings that include specialty chocolates, baked goods and deli items, Wild Plum gives skiers, resort guests and local residents an easy place to satisfy a sweet craving.

Fuzziwig's Candy Factory

Colorful displays and an abundance of sweets create a playful atmosphere at Fuzziwig's Candy Factory on Lincoln Avenue in downtown Steamboat Springs. Beyond its selection of bulk candies, fudge and caramel apples, the shop serves hand-dipped premium ice cream in traditional and novelty flavors. Customers can choose waffle cones, sundaes, milkshakes and ice cream sandwiches, with candy toppings adding extra sweetness and crunch. The combination of frozen desserts and confectionery favorites makes Fuzziwig's a stop for families and visitors exploring the downtown shopping district.

Johnny B. Good's Diner

Classic ice cream fountain treats are part of the retro dining experience at Johnny B. Good's Diner on Lincoln Avenue in downtown Steamboat Springs. Inspired by the diners of the 1950s, the restaurant serves hand-spun milkshakes, malts, sundaes, egg creams and root beer floats made with premium ice cream. Neon signs, jukeboxes and vinyl booths contribute to the nostalgic surroundings, making a visit feel like a trip to another era. Guests can enjoy their frozen favorites on their own or alongside traditional diner meals such as burgers and fries.

Created or enhanced with ChatGPT.